debate

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
how is one plant alerting another plant that its in danger proof that it feels pain?
heres my proof that they do not feel pain
"Given that plants do not have pain receptors, nerves, or a brain, they do not feel pain as we members of the animal kingdom understand it. Uprooting a carrot or trimming a hedge is not a form of botanical torture, and you can bite into that apple without worry. However, it seems that many plants can perceive and communicate physical stimuli and damage in ways that are more sophisticated than previously thought.
Some plants have obvious sensory abilities, such as the Venus flytrap and its incredible traps that can close in about half a second. Similarly, the sensitive plant rapidly collapses its leaves in response to touch, an adaptation that might serve to startle away potential herbivores. While these plants visibly display a clear sensory capacity, recent research has shown that other plants are able to perceive and respond to mechanical stimuli at a cellular level. Arabidopsis (a mustard plant commonly used in scientific studies) sends out electrical signals from leaf to leaf when it is being eaten by caterpillars or aphids, signals to ramp up its chemical defenses against herbivory. While this remarkable response is initiated by physical damage, the electrical warning signal is not equivalent to a pain signal, and we should not anthropomorphize an injured plant as a plant in pain. Plants have exceptional abilities to respond to sunlight, gravity, wind, and even tiny insect bites, but (thankfully) their evolutionary successes and failures have not been shaped by suffering, just simple life and death."
i debunk your claims by simply saying that they are basic rudimentary functions for survival, nothing close to being able to precieve and process something as complex as pain
even some oysters are believed to not feel pain, so im not buying that something as basic as plants can

Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
commented on
debate
Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/09/plants-communicate-distress-using-their-own-kind-nervous-system more evidence

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
yes, plants can communicate with each other
how does this link to them processing pain?

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
look, my problem is im coming from a stance of "heres biologically why they can not feel pain as compared to how animals feel pain"
and from my point of view your coming with "but they can do other things that are surprising." without anything linking that to the ability to feel pain
it just isnt the same, do you see where im coming from?

Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
commented on
debate
Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
well if they are essentaly warning other plants is shows they feel some sort of pain

Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
commented on
debate
Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
but multiple studys show like i have shown multiple times that plants do feel some type of pain

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
no, theyr warning other plants of danger because they are injured
not in pain
injured
they can tell that they are injured and show self preservalence as well as a signal to its other kind to preserve itself, but again this does not mean they feel pain and id like to know how you link the two with some biological evidence

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
knowing your injured does not = pain

Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
commented on
debate
Caleb of the cancer @caleb_williams
yet when we are injured we feel pain it only logically makes sense that they feel some sort of pain

Lamby @momoichi
commented on
debate
Lamby @momoichi
biologically we can prove they dont have the capability to feel pain
"Given that plants do not have pain receptors, nerves, or a brain, they do not feel pain as we members of the animal kingdom understand it."
can plants become stressed? sure, but its not the same as pain
Please login to post.