Log in with your MaiOtaku account.
Home Forum Anime Members Help

Would you live in an anarchist government?

tabris
This account has been suspended.
vezax
Jul 14, 18 at 11:49am
I wouldnt live in such a world.. if all humans there are logical beings then i would be more than happy to live there, it would have been my utopia! But humans are emotional idiots so i wouldnt live in an unregulated country :/ the best example of a place which is nearest to total anarchist would be bangkok (thailand), its a good place for vacation and drugs.. but as a place to live i wouldnt prefer there.
weebian
When there are absence of leadership, some will rise to acclaim power (A.K.A the mafia). It is in human nature to have a hierarchy in a way that will help steer their future with a sense of control of their lives (or greatly improve it). An anarchist government will only rise the rates of crimes and poverty, where the rich will own pretty much everything (since police and fire departments would be subscription based). They might have a privatized police force to protect themselves from others. Also scientists' studies and research cannot be done without money. Since the rich (and mafia) will be the only ones who can provide them money, they will be forced into a position where they must submit skewed researched and create something new that will benefit those with an agenda. The problem with all these ideologies and types of ideal government is that it never considered someone that would try to abuse the system or take into account of human nature.
burninghalo
Weebian is right. Anarchy inevitably ALWAYS creates a power vacuum and someone will fill the role. It's just how humans are. Also, I'm not so sure that you want a world where scientists and other professions are not bound by some ethical code. They are there for a reason.
sir_loligagger_faded_face
Would I choose to live in that world as in I actively take steps to convert this world into that? No Would I continue to live in that world if I was born in it? Yes
sir_loligagger_faded_face
I want to keep this separate from my answer and you can skip this Tabris as this is more in general not really directed at anyone just at the "Idea". The idea of an anarchist government wouldn't last long because of human nature. People that are born leaders would start hoarding power. They would monopolize and form tribes which would spread and take from the weak. Major stifling would occur as the focus of others would turn to the self. Long-term selfish behavior with no need to adapt or innovate. If any innovation comes it would be slow and have limitations as a stronger brute would force a weaker smart person to make things for them. A smart person would have to either fear being taken away and get little work done or not care and then be taken away. Artist would still starve as the market would be absent to value them and the work and even if they did have a market it would be cells. Isolated cell markets with little to no growth or reach. Resources and the management of that would need to happen if these things are all under the foot of a tyrant with mercs. Would it play out 100% like this no and I bet that there are endless creative ways it could go wrong and the few times it may ever go right is just way to small to even consider when we have better options. It's kinda in the same predicament as "true socialism" it's never happened for a reason as it's just a dream of one man. A dream with no account for the individual's mind and free will leads to a mess.
tabris
This account has been suspended.
yamadaed
This account has been suspended.
vezax
Pic
Pic
Pic
^India is nowhere near anarchist.. drugs is not common here, people don't have access to weapons, depressive/mood disorders are uncommon, we don't have as much freedom as the developed countries, underage sex is almost non-existent, most of the citizens are very cultural which gives them a high sense of respect towards nature (and also superstitions)! i know there is a lot of internet trolling going on about india.. but they are just desperate guys asking for bobs and vaganas ;_; (jk jk) tbh such guys are out there everywhere, here the population is high so maybe u see more of them plus they are among the least literate group so their english makes them stand out. and its funny that you mention about various crimes as the reason for not living in India, here is screenshot of countries listed according to crime rate:- 1. mexico is ranked 20 with 19.26 2. US is ranked 87 with 5.35 3. India is ranked 119 with 3.22 which is really low compared to where you live and to US! If there is anything serious to be worried about if u visit or live in India then its the poverty and communicable diseases, we probably top the list in that criteria.. *source for the screenshots:- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate
tabris
This account has been suspended.
Continue
Please login to post.